The Best Organic Crib Mattress – Top 3 Crib Mattresses This Year

whats the best organic crib mattress brand for a baby

Looking for the best organic crib mattress reviews? Most first-time parents will spend countless hours researching prospective baby products to ensure they make a well-informed, value-conscious decision.

You Want The Best…

Why not? You want the best for your baby, but who has the time?? Look no further.

I have compiled my own research into three short product reviews. My sweet baby girl Daisy currently sleeps on one of these very mattresses.

However, before you read any further, make sure you are aware of all that features and benefits the best organic crib mattress has to offer.
Check out my article on Why It’s Worth Investing in an Organic Crib Mattress before you go on to read the best organic crib mattress reviews below.

3 Of The Best Quality Organic Crib Mattresses

Organic Mattresses

Brand Name

Star Rating

More Details

2 Stage Naturepedic Ultra Breathable Organic Crib Mattress

4 / 5 Stars

2 Stage 150 Coil Naturepedic Classic Organic Crib Mattress

4.7 / 5 Stars

Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic

4.7 / 5 Stars

1) Best Organic Crib Mattress: 2 Stage Naturepedic Ultra Breathable Organic Crib Mattress

The multi award winning and family owned company Naturepedic created the industry’s first phthalate-free, waterproof crib mattress with the introduction of its 2 stage Organic Crib Mattress

The Ultra Breathable 2-Stage starts your baby off with a firm, flat crib mattress for added safety. To help keep baby dry and cool, we add a breathable mattress pad on top of the crib mattress. The breathable pad maximizes airflow between the baby and mattress for a comfortable sleep with reduced risk of overheating.

Stain And Waterproof Covers

Instead of vinyl, Naturepedic uses pure food-grade polyethylene for the ultimate in stain and waterproofing its crib mattresses in a clean white finish, preventing your baby’s mattress from becoming a potential breeding ground for bacteria or mold. Polyethylene has a natural flexibility and softness, making it the ideal hygienic material for keeping babies mattresses clean and stain free.

Benefits of the Naturepedic Organic Crib Mattress:

  • Luxurious patented wavesupport technology gives baby the ultimate sleep support for comfort
  • Everything made entirely in the USA from USDA certified sources
  • Waterproof Surface -easy-to-clean 100% polyethylene food grade waterproof surface
  • Organic Cotton Filling –100% organic cotton encourages a healthy and chemical free sleeping environment
  • Organic cotton is naturally renewable, unbleached, not dyed, and grown without health disrupting pesticides, herbicides, or chemical fertilizers
  • Hypoallergenic Dust Mite Barrier Cover

Naturepedic make award winning crib mattresses especially to create a healthy sleep environment for babies and their mattresses for babies are filled with organically grown cotton which is grown in the USA. This way you can be assured there are no toxic nasties hidden away.

Naturepedic Use Only Organic Cotton Farmed In The USA

“The USDA certified organic cotton filling is a natural and renewable fiber which is renewable, unbleached, undyed and grown without any chemical fertilizers, synthetic herbicides and pesticides. There is no polyurethane foam used in the manufacture of these award-winning mattresses”

Non Toxic And Fire Safe

The Naturepedic baby and toddler mattress also has a non-toxic, naturally derived fire barrier system that exceeds Federal flammability standards and meets the GREENGUARD® GOLD certification standards. Naturepedic mattresses are recommended by the Healthy Child Healthy World coalition.

The Ultra Breathable Mattress Pad provides air circulation without the hygiene risks of non-waterproof breathable mattresses to help baby breathe safely for your baby as recommended by pediatricians and the Consumer Product Safety Commission recommendation.

Naturepedic uses only U.S. grown and certified organic cotton as filling for its mattresses and buys directly from USDA certified sources. This increases purity, organic reliability and support for U.S. farmers.

2) 2 Stage Naturepedic Classic 252 Coil Organic Crib Mattress

The Naturepedic Breathable Organic Crib Mattress is a luxurious step up from the Classic Series. For the discerning parent who is willing to spend a little more, this organic cotton crib mattress offers a top of the range quality mattress with the materials used and with the addition of a thick quilted top layer for extra baby comfort.

Benefits of the Naturepedic Organic Quilted Cotton Deluxe Mattress:

  • 3D Mesh surface for added breathability and safety if baby sleeps face down
  • Made entirely in the USA by Naturepedic, a multi award winning, family owned company
  • Thick quilted and USDA certified and sourced 100% organic cotton fabric surface with a smooth sateen finish
  • 100% non-dyed and unbleached pure organic cotton filling
  • 252 Orthopedic innerspring coils for superior firmness as recommended by pediatricians
  • Heavy-duty border rods for extra side wall strength and 9 gauge edge support stops sagging
  • Non-toxic, naturally derived fire barrier system surpasses Federal flammability standards
  • Measures 27.5″ x 52″ x 6″ which also fits toddler beds and day beds

If you want to provide your baby with a top-of-the-line organic crib mattress in pure organic cotton by Naturepedic, this deluxe quilted mattress is definitely the best quality mattress you can get.

Filled With USDA Certified Pure Organic Cotton

It is filled with 100% USDA certified pure organic cotton from USA farmers which guarantees a safe, healthy and chemical-free sleeping environment without any toxic off gassing for your baby. This is especially important as they spend so much of their time asleep. The cotton is grown in the USA and is both unbleached and non-dyed, as well is being grown without any chemical fertilizers and pesticides.

Quilted Top For Added Comfort

“The surface of the Naturepedic mattress is made from thick quilted organic cotton. It looks similar to the quilted topping which you see on adult beds which adds an extra layer of comfort, while still retaining the mattress firmness pediatricians recommended for babies so they lie flat”

No Potential Allergens

organic baby crib certification

There are no potential high allergy materials such as latex, wool, coir or polyurethane foam used which are often found in cheaper mattresses. There is only 100% organic cotton from only certified US farmers used in the manufacturing of these organic baby crib mattresses. You can be safe in the knowledge your baby’s health is looked after by choosing a good quality mattress for her.

Pediatricians Recommend Babies Lie On Firm Mattresses

Pediatricians recommend that babies lie on a firm and supportive mattress on their backs and the heavy duty, 252 orthopedic innerspring coils plus the quilted firm and flat surface provide the perfect support in accordance with the Consumer Product Safety Commission firmness recommendations.

Award Winning Designs

Again, these award-winning mattresses incorporate Fire Protection which is a non toxic fire protection system legislated by the Federal and State flammability standards without using potentially harmful chemicals in case of fire

3) Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic

The Naturepedic Breathable Organic Crib Mattress by award winning company Naturepedic provides all the benefits of the No-Compromise Organic Cotton Classic Series, but without the coils.

The Naturepedic is a dual stage mattress weighing about 20 pounds and is designed to last with a firmer side for babies and a cushioned firm side for toddlers. It has a 100% polyethylene, easy to clean, waterproof surface made from pure organic cotton which is non-toxic, making it the perfect choice for parents who want to eliminate nasty chemicals and allergens.

Benefits of the Naturepedic Organic Mattress:

  • 100% organic cotton fabric and filling with firm and comfortable
  • Patented Wave Support Inner for extra comfort and support of baby bodies
  • Made in USA from guaranteed USDA certified farmers with 100% guaranteed organic materials
  • 2-Stage dual mattress
  • Firmer infant side as recommended by pediatricians and Healthy Child healthy World organization
  • Softer toddler side for when they are that much older
  • Waterproof and wipe clean hygienic surface
  • Waterproof seams prevent moisture penetration, stopping allergens and mold growing, allowing for easier cleaning
  • Measures 27.75″ x 52″ x 6″ with square corners for a snug crib fit

Which Is The Best 2 Stage Mattress?

If you’re looking for an organic baby crib mattress to suit your baby and as they grow into a toddler, this is the perfect two-stage mattress with dual firmness.

As recommended by pediatricians, your baby needs a firm and supportive surface to lie on in those crucial early months. As they grow older, they can progress to a softer cushioned, less firm surface which the Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic provides. This choice offers you the safety infants need and the comfort toddlers like to snuggle into. This makes it a good economic choice and as the mattress is designed to be long-lasting, you get value for your money.

As Naturepedic is a family owned company, their baby crib mattresses have been rigorously tested for any chemical emissions and are fully certified to meet GREENGUARD® GOLD standards. Your child can sleep in a chemical free, cleaner environment which is important when they are young.

organic baby crib mattress lifetime warranty

The crib mattress is covered with luxurious pure organic cotton. The cotton fabric is treated and impregnated with a 100% polyethylene waterproof surface. The polyethylene Naturepedic uses is so pure it meets food contact standards which is reassuring to know.

Stain Resistant And Waterproof

This offers the benefits of being the ultimate stain resistant and waterproof mattress cover which is what you want. You don’t want any leakage, possibly causing a breeding ground for bacteria and mold. Interestingly, this waterproof surface acts to work as a dust mite or bedbug barrier and it’s presented in a clean crisp white finish.

Rest assured this mattress offers a firm surface in accordance with pediatrician and U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) recommendations.

So Which Is The Best Organic Crib Mattress Daisy Sleeps On?

daisy in her crib on a100% organic cotton mattress, Best Organic Crib Mattress
Daisy in her crib on a 100% organic cotton mattress

After navigating through a multitude of sales literature and online reviews, the above three mattresses appealed to me as the best organic crib mattress reviews at varying price points.

My choice for Daisy was the Naturepedic 2 stage Breathable Organic Crib Mattress. It offered all the essential benefits of a certified organic crib mattress while maintaining the perfect balance between luxury and affordability. And of course she is growing so fast, it won’t be long before she’ll need a toddler bed!



Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top